Both at their maximum capacity and gear. Who the fuck wins?
Geralt
>>710281229
probably guts
>>710281229
Guts
Geralt
This is a tough one, but my vote goes to geralt, his arsenal is more diverse and guts relies mostly just on brute strenght.
>>710281357
nigga you wish
Guts would win, yet both would die
Easily Guts
>>710281571
>>710281229
GUTS. ALL. DAY. LONG.
Geralt
On potions he was fucking unstoppable.
>>710281229
Guts because the witcher fucking blows
Blood & Wine endgame Geralt is a fucking beast with mutations and potions.
none of you faggots provided an explanation behind your choices
>>710282383
Ok
See that big weeaboo sword on the guy on the left ?
The guy on the right is very fucking fast, end even fucking faster on potions.
Big weeaboo sword takes time to swing, by the time he has momentum he's headless because the witcher is much faster.
>>710282585
have you even seen how fast he can swing that shit in the games/anima/manga/whatever? His greatsword is like thor's hammer, impossible to use for anyone else, but he can swing that shit like it's nothing
>>710281229
guts no contest
Don't know the weeb faggot, but Geralt can actually swing his sword, weeby McNip couldn't if he tried
>>710282846
This. He also has a full auto crossbow and a cannon on his arm. Also he isn't a fag who needs potions to fight.
>>710282846
No I haven't I'm not a fucking weeabo to watch manga / anime
>>710281229
Don't know who the guy on the right is. Can someone tell me all his powers and skills?
>>710282585
Sounds like you don't know anything about Gutts, other then le big animu sword.
>>710283116
have you played dark soul?
Geralt wouldn't even be found under all that pussy he gets
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJCtd1IxBqs
yeah, geralt is kill
>>710283107
Clearly you haven't seen the show but he can swing his sword surprisingly quick and take out 20 people with a single swing. Apparently butt boy can't do anything without his little potions.
>>710283207
Nope
>>710283297
this, his harem will protect him
>>710283387
Geralt would slap down yrden and fuck him up
>>710282585
>i play shitty vidya and am a massive faggot who doesnt know anything about berzerk
Fixd
>>710283116
you read manga you dense fuck
>>710281229
Guts can't win cuz he was on a boat for 7 years.
>>710283116
So youre a faggot
Just like we said
>>710283573
No you read fucking books, manga is mostly pictures not to strain weeaboo brain
okay i don't know a damn thing about the witcher, just how god modded can you get?
is it worth playing?
>>710282585
Faggot kill yourself >>710283563
was right, Geralt is a pussy.
>>710283561
Exactly what I was thinking.
>>710283573
>read images
Sure.
>>710283307
this game is so shit though, guts was NEVER this strong in anime or manga, they just made him that strong to make a dinasty warriors clone, not to mention other characters are insanelly OP as well
>>710283770
Are you for story over gameplay?
>>710281229
Lets see an unstoppable black knight capable of killing Lovecraftian abominations with haste that is immune to all pain and have a ridiculously huge amount of strength or a very skilled witch hunter
gee OP what a fair fight.
>>710281229
They become good friends, faggot.
>be Geralt
>use slowing spell (Yrden)
>Guts is slowed
>use Sword to hack him to bits
>>710284046
Probably
>>710283952
gameplay over story any day
game can have the most garbage story imaginable and i'll love it if it's fun enough to play
>>710283826
fucking kek
>>710283972
obviously, you haven't played any of the witcher games or know anything about it's lore. Geralt is not a witch hunter, he's a MONSTER hunter, and he killed just as many if not more lovecraftian abominations
>>710283387
if brute force was so essential I wonder why we use heads instead
and whats wrong with potions? everyone has different weapons
I have to admit that guts has more strenght, but other than that hes nothing and Geralt could easily dodge his swings .. so yeah my bet is on Geralt
will guts ever smile again?
>>710281229
>maximum capacity and gear.
IM SORRY I CANTY HEAR YOU OVER THE SOUND OF AAAAAAARGGGHGHAGHAHH MURDERKILLRAPEFLAYEATKILLRAPEMUDER
>>710283387
I hate Eastern character design so much, it's why I don't watch anime or any of that gay shit
>>710284305
Not until he kills all the members of God Hand and Griffith
>>710284192
Then you will probably not like the series, the gameplay sucks.
>>710284412
he'll never smile again then
>>710284365
My sides hurt. And same.
>>710284365
made me lol
>>710284365
Poland is not from the West, mate.
>>710281229
>>710284444
the gameplay is fine, as long as you play on the highest difficulty, it requires good reaction speed
>>710284666
fuck off underage cancer
>>710284666
gtfo
>>710284666
this is exactly what >>710284365 is refering to
There's no actual point on that bald cunt's strenght other than "Because of yes"
>>710284228
>witcher games
nigga get back when you´ve read the books
geralt is literally protected by 4km thick plot armor and is more or less just a normal human
>>710284666
kys scum
>>710281229
Guts would do his God-mode Monster-Killer Demon-Lord-Skull-Suit shit and one shot that fool. It would be all over. It's magic.
>>710284228
have you even seen the world where guts lives literally everything is a lovecraftian abomination.
Gerald will get his shit pushed in right away.
>>710284365
>SHOULD SHOW GREAT LEADERSHIP
Clearly fucking westerns needing to be shilled and controled by an alpha
congratulations, you played yourself
>>710283563
>I'm proud of my weaboo autism
Anime is for children, grow up Kevin.
>>710284057
that would require him to step on it
>>710284666
im just waiting for the day ONE ends the series with saitama losing trolling the ENTIRE community to the depths of hades
>>710284956
anime is for manchild though
vidya is for children
>>710284829
you said "witch hunter" which shows you know fuck all
>>710284632
he said anime
>>710284228
>Monster Hunter
Dude, Guts goes up against Demi-gods before finishing breakfast. Guts is so much bullshit. He's not a game character, he's a manga character first and foremost, and he is practically fucking immortal considering he's basically been to hell and back and more shit than you can imagine without reading the manga.
>>710284956
>Anime is for children, grow up Kevin.
Oh this b8 again.
>>710285050
nigga wrong person i aint never called Geralt a witch hunter
Dropped in a box outside of both of their respective universes. Guts.
In Witcher universe. Guts.
In Berserk universe. Geralt.
>Gutz killed over 100 man in a night or less
>Survived the hand of god
>Wasnt born and raised with fucking mutagens
>Tfw gutz is the medieval version of batman (Self improvement wize)
>>710284876
this is not his world, it's just the astral plane he visits a few times. witcher and berserk worlds are almost the same
Geralt would obviously seduce him and fuck him to death. Geralt wins
>>710281229
I don't even know who Guts is tbh fam.
Guts far outclasses Geralt in speed, durability, strength and hitting power even without his berserker's armor. Geralt's swords would break with the first hit against the dragonslayer. Geralt's magical signs are also very weak compared to what Guts has faced before. So in a strait up fight, Guts will take this one 9/10 times.
Given prep time, I would give Geralt a 6/10 chance of winning, assuming he is able to dictate the time and location of the fight. Geralt is very good at preparing and adapting his strategy to perfectly combat any opponent, so via the use of poisons, hexes and potions there is probably a winning strategy available to him, given his expansive knowledge and combat experience.
>>710284824
i think there's a difference
saintama's strength is a joke that keeps the series running, its for the purpose of satire
>>710285225
explain why they'd lose in their own universe
>>710285308
kek
Geralt, the stone cold pimp.
>>710285225
explain?
>>710285043
Both are pure autism. I don't understand how so many people in here claim loud and proud that they watch anime or play games based on fantasy books.
>u know nothin bout berserk bro xd
>m-muh killing monsters
>>710281229
Guts hands down.
Geralta like captain america, basically at the peak of possible human condition and he still routinely struggles to kill shit like werewolves and the like.
Guts is a literal fucking monster who passed up geralts stats at age 16 in all categories. He's only gotten better since and he routinely kills shit like werewolves and demons literally every night until sunrise as just a matter of life.
Magic MIGHT help geralt a bit but you have to realize guts literally can't lose so long as he thinks he can't do to being 1/3 in the upper realm and therefore mind of matter yadda yadda broken weeb magic.
Tl;dr its just plain not a fair match up. Try something like geralt versus your low-tier marvel superhero or guts versus some other equally broken thing.
>>710285226
>not mentioning how shockful of arcane energy Guts is
in term of magic bullshit Guts and Geralt are more or less the same Geralts mutagen bullshit however is focused and pinpointed whereas Guts is just a fucking battery of raw power
>>710285226
nah, geralt is the batman here in all aspects, just because geralt is a mutant, doesn't mean he didn't have to work his ass off to improve himself
>>710281874
the injuries sustained during the battle would kill guts once the armors effect wears off
>>710285225
It wouldn't matter where they fought, Guts would win. Guts fights gargantuan eldritch abominations underwater, ffs. Against impossible odds.
Guts has also never had a game over screen, whereas everyone who plays Geralt has seen him die easily enough.
>>710281229
I'd say the guy carrying a fucking steel beam would probably win
>>710285470
you gotta be baiting, no way an autist of your level would be roaming this realm...
oh wait, this is /b/ after all
>>710285470
because anime is all about fighting, sexualized little girl, magic, fantasy, etc amirite?
>>710285238
>this is not his world, it's just the astral plane he visits a few times.
It don't change the fact that Geralt will get literally raped if he sets a foot in one of those places.
>>710286074
Yes.
>>710284365
Rest assured that you don't know what you are talking about and are simply reveling in ignorance.
Speed does not trump size and strength. Otherwise we wouldn't break boxing up into weight classes.
>>710285328
this guy
>>710283116
And yet here you are posting in this thread about anime character. Now what does it make you if not as you so eloquently put it a.fucking weeabo?
>>710286138
>inb4 Psycho Pass
>>710285238
>this is not his world, it's just the astral plane he visits a few times
have you even read the later chapters?
THAT IS THE WORLD NOW
>>710286182
>no ur wrong ok? muh anime is better you're clearly an ignorant
>>710285342
Geralt wouldn't parry his Sword but dodge it if he had time to prepare before battle he would already know that Guts strength is similar to monster. However in the end I bet on Guts he would win not becose of his strength but durability.
>>710286239
That's only in hand to hand combat. With tools, speed is almost everything.
That said, guts in his suit is always as fast as he needs to be because MAGIC POWERS, DAWG
>>710286138
then you are baiting
Geralt couldnt survive what guts went through with griffith and that huge sacrifice. I like both but Im going to give ti to guts simply because his strength and Geralt i dont even think has the strength to cut him. Guys catches blades with his hands man lol
>>710281567
He does not rely on brute strength you cocksucker.
>>710286405
>Geralt couldnt survive what guts went through with griffith and that huge sacrifice.
Guts would not have either had it not been for Skellyknight mane
>>710286239
yes, but in boxing they don't use swords or axes that require considerably less strenght to inflict a lethal wound as opposed to plain fists
>>710286331
No, just what he said is all based on an ignorant rationalization. The world is a little more complicated than that. Western heros are literal faggot cucks sometimes, and Eastern heros are classic fantasy protagonists at times.
>>710286239
>there are people in the world right now who actually believe this
>>710286402
>lol nice bait bro lmsao uy fkin loser ur wrong and everybody knows lmao gko kill urself
>>710286182
This is the character design for most anime, and the plot is always "I want to be the very best" just made edgy and with unnatural lines and cringey, unrealistic characters
>>710284260
How does guts get through berserk armor, guts has more durability
>>710286548
THIS all day
Guts uses SOOOO many tools killing shit hes more or less a bulkier version of geralt
>>710285499
Guts isnt broken, He wins because of all his experience. Every time he fights some strong hes always about to die then he resorts to cheap tricks like bombs.
> believing guts wouldn't completely murder geralt
>mfw
>>710286405
he is pretty strong.
>>710286318
no, berserk world was just a regular medieval world, and then when the magic merging bullshit happened, it became on par with witcher world in terms of monsters and shit
>>710286401
HE HAS A CANNON FOR AN ARM
>>710286604
i'm ready if you want to do a real argument though
>>710286595
Well, he's right in hand to hand combat. But outside of organized sports, tools are king, and speed and accuracy rule. It doesn't matter how strong something is if you can drop a missile on a dime in their backyard from the other side of the world, for example. let alone simply sniping.
>>710283667
underrated keks
The main problem with this argument is the context of it all.
First, Berserk is still ongoing so we haven't actually seen Gutz's maximum capacity. There's no way to truly compare them.
Second, the Witcher universe and Berserk have a completely different set of rules. The Witcher universe is a lot more strict, Geralt is considered one of the best fighters on the continent but this is due to Witcher mutations and potions. He is essentially an enhanced human, but still a human. No human could ever, ever swing a sword as big as Gutz's. And magic is someone people have to slave over for lifetimes in order to gain even a little bit of power over. There are literally about 6 mages/sorcoresses in the Witcher.
And that leads into Berserk, where magic is anywhere and all you need is an affinity for the elements and a "spirit infused" weapon to use it. Then lets go on to the fact Gutz can wield that sword. Yeah. And lets also not forget his berserk armor, where he loses control but gets 10x stronger.
>pic related
Plus there's a guy that rose an entire city out of the ground using the power of his mind.
Yeah.
TL;DR: Gutz would win, because their universes follow completely different rules and we haven't even reached his peak yet.
>>710285138
Guts fights demons and abominations pretty much everyday, while gerald is skilled, guts would kill the shit out of him
>>710286551
That is still up for debate. Guts plays a bigger role then what weve seen in the manga the author says. Im guessing guts would have made it out regardless but no one else. Something about their being 5 gods hands but theres also another force the author hasnt come out with yet. He said at a conference that guts could be an arch angel in human flesh
>>710286658
No, that's just you generalizing because you probably don't have the wherewithal or interest to actually look into it.
>>710286658
>>710286808
>this is not even my final form I was just trollin' ;)))) Come at me anyday tho
You're so sad bro I'm tired of this shit
Praise the sun
>>710286791
>merging bullshit happened
might as well be as horrible as the Sacrificial shithole
the magic merging bullshit applies to both series however
although the witcher universe is by far more lenient than the Berserk one
>>710285238
>it's just the astral plane
NOT ANYMORE
>>710286925
I agree.
In fact, I think the general consensus is a Guts win.
>>710286983
whatever helps you sleep at night.
i didn't know you have an extra chromosome, sorry anon
>>710287236
It doesnt change the fact that Guys at a young age even before they started showing magic in Berserk is still stronger then Geralt.
But there is 1 factor that plays in that we dont know how it would effect guts and that is geralts mind control crap. If guts cant resist that guts loses
>>710286246
Ah, the Hawks translation.
All this people believing that Geralt can stand a chance against Guts.
>>710286885
>universes follow completely different rules
and yet they are pretty similar
i mean just the arcane world and the normal one merging cuz dick magic users is pretty funny
do you niggers even know how vast Geralt's arsenal is? he's literally batman and he has a counter for anything even if he's not as strong as Guts.
>>710286878
No hes not.
Speed generates power.
The whole speed vs power arguement is 100% retarded either way you look at it because they are not mutually exclusive.
>>710287437
>mind control crap. If guts CAN resist that
he could if
" maximum capacity" includes schierke
>>710287722
well gut's is an improved batman
>>710286658
"Hahaha you're wrong because you're wrong, I don't have any reasoning, but it's you"
>>710286694
Either you're missing something or you just didn't pay attention.
Guts has always had a connection to the upper realm simply due to his birth stemming from death and thus being born "partly dead". In that particular realm your will is infact reality.
This is why guts has always been able to do crazily inhuman shit, with a bit of prodding, as he just plain isn't limited by the middle realms rules like most everyone else is. This is why he can cut demons offhandedly with any weapon or why he can swing a literal ton of metal by age 14. Its why he's always able to step up to the plate and down shit that should absolutely have liquified him into a fine past like the sea lords heart should have.
It's only gotten worse with the addition of the armor and his injury thats locked even more of him on the other side, hence why he can't live outside the armor for very long now. He also is wielding a sword, armor, and body thats become a relic via being literally drenched on a weekly basis in demonic blood and having existed in several of the realms at various points.
He's just plain broken cause he's wielding god killing weaponry ontop of being a demigod himself.
This is the same shit that happened to the skeleton night and its starting to happen to guts.
>>710287927
only in looks
>>710287722
Does he have a counter for being in a shitty series?
>>710287926
Guts maximum is going to be him ascending the same way Griffith did
>>710286885
>There are literally about 6 mages/sorcoresses in the Witcher.
There's a lot more than that, but you're right in that magic is relatively uncommon.
>>710287903
Dude,if you're being for real, you need to understand that in reality, people don't have RPG stats. Agility IS strength because you can't be agile without being strong. Real life has no min-max builds because any speed requires muscle strength to carry out.
Speed doesn't generate power, it's the other way around. The strength allows the speed to be generated. You've never seen a real acrobat or professional gymnast with low strength.
>>710288098
Thats an opinion but not in the story though. The God hands i remember acknowledging the Skeleknight but theres been nothing else about him
>>710288204
W3 is the best game ever made, according to alot of people.
>>710288098
you sir are a saint
>>710288214
>limiting Guts to Griffiths meager existence
if guts ascends he will far TRANCEND Griffith and the godhand hell he´ll probvs just go crazy and consume everything turning into some sort of wolf monster or some shit
>>710288470
according to alot of plebeians
>ftfy
>>710288474
Guts only reason to move forward is to go after Griffith, with out that hes nothing.
One more vote for Guts.
Just look at all the shit Guts went through, the monsters he fought and the hellish world he lives in. Geralt's world is a paradise in comparison.
They aren't even remotely on the same level. Geralt would be ripped apart in no time.
Geralt.
Guts easily
Geralt is a walking faggot
>>710281229
Geralt of course
>>710288448
Its from the big "wipe" the author did cause he gave away WAY to much in various chapters so he sort of did a wipe of those chapters even existing.
He did say they were canon just that he wants a slower "leak" of info.
Ex: It's canon that in their universe the concept of "hell" is just a whirlpool of souls forever stuck in moments of torment and that when you die no matter what kind of person you are you'll be thrown into one of these whirlpools just because it keeps the GodHand in power.
>>710287722
Guts just has to move his sword slightly to cut the faggot in half he don't even have to use that much power to kill such a weak enemy as Geralt, hell guts might be fighting a bunch of demons at the same time and he won't even notice that he killed Geralt in the process.
you know something that just hit me?
we are using the wrong method to determine whos the strongest
instead of pitting them against each other we should have them face each others foes?
Geralt fighting Apostles and Guts facing like a fiend or something else big?
guess it´ll be harder to put Guts against something really powerful from the witcher series since those monsters are limited to bosses and such
Yrden.
Geralt.
>>710288424
You literally said the exact same thing i did but your reasoning is back assdwards
If what you said was true musclemen would be the fastest mother fuckers alive, and we all know thats not the case.
>>710289181
That's a cool idea. Geralt would probably be better equipped to fight the Apostles because he has magic and shit, which Guts doesn't.
>>710287927
Quit calling Guts Batman. They are completely separate.
>>710288470
There are a lot of dumb motherfuckers in the world.
>>710288740
There are many situations where Guts literally got lucky.
Also, if a strong human could survive the hardships you're talking about, what makes you think a superhuman couldn't survive them.
>>710281229
Geralt. He throws a dimeritium bomb and cancels out Guts' anime bullshit. Or he casts Yrden or Axii to give him just enough time to cut his arm off.
>>710289448
then again the only REALLY powerful foe Geralt has ever faced is Eredin whos is a fart in space compared to some of the Apostles
>>710289181
NOSFERATU ZODD would shit all over gestalt
>>710289655
>implying losing an arm would stop guts
You /v/ faggots are hilarious
>>710281229
Guts, geralt is a punk bitch who probably cant take much more than some light stabbing
>>710281229
Kratos would win he's the God of war
>>710289805
not a chance
GANISHKA HOWEVER
so long as Geralt dont find his body (and even if he did hed have to fight a million monsters just to get to him) hes toast
>>710289999
Quads confirms, thread over folks
>>710281229
the chosen undead tbh
>>710289397
It sounds like you are buying into some stereotyped generalizations to me. You can be strong and fast, but you can't have speed without strength.
anyway, I'm talking about reality, not, how fast you can push a button or how many pounds you can deadlift.
>>710290037
Guts would wipe out all of greek mythology before lunch and call it a light day
>>710289991
It didn't stop him the first time, what will the second time will do?
Guts wins every time. Geralt in the books is actually not quite as badass as the games make him seem. The books have a real deconstruction like quality to them. His fallibility is a major aspect of his character actually. Even if you include his game feats, he'd lose
The sigils and magic Geralt has gives him an insurmountable advantage. Potions are just icing on the cake. Theres no real reason to believe Guts would be impervious to Axii or Yrden, and Quen is broken as it is. Once he employs these all he really has to do is slice Guts up.
>>710281229
Fucking Guts man
>>710289999
quads has spoken. guts wins.
>>710290317
Especially the God of War's Greek mythology, though even if Guts does win, Kratos will come right back.
The shit guts have to face and the shit Geralt have to face are at completely different levels of power, also gut's is from a manga so that makes him even more broken.
>>710290317
Guts?! More like 'needs guts'! Ha take that butt hurt gut fucker!
>>710283424
Wow you're just a fag aren't you? Go back to sucking your dad's dick to get the approval he never plans on giving you.
Guts, no question
>>710284957
In the novel's Yrden is not just AoE. It can be cast direct onto something.
>>710281229
Good luck trying to swing that giant 400 ton sword
Geralt would fuck him up in 2seconds
>>710290190
No, youre not. Youre retarded.
Do you not know what mutually exclusive means?
It means you can't have one without the other, so since I said they are not mutually exclusive that would mean that the whole arguement is stupid because the idea of having one without the other, i.e. speed without strength or vice versa just isn't plausable.
There, now that I explained it to you like a fucking child do you understand it? Do you know what plausable means?
And you just have to go and shit yourself and put dem pants on your head and vomit some bullshit about speed not generating power. Do you even understand like physics? I mean fucksake kid, give it up.
>>710290951
What is that supposed to be, like a summon? Dude, Esoteric Skellyknight would pop out of fucking nowhere and Deus Ex Machina a win for Guts.
>>710284711
I just never liked the combat. Difficulty did nothing for me.
>>710291164
anon, guts is so strong that he can swing it like he's swinging a plastic bat, and that even before he's wearing berserk armor
>>710291251
>Do you not know what mutually exclusive means?
>It means you can't have one without the other
Nigger, you're retarded.
Mutually exclusive means that you can only have one OR the other. Choosing one excludes the other one. Mutually. Hence, mutually exclusive.
>>710281229
HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!HAI YAI FORCES!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xj1hWWU8JDE
>>710291305
Sounds gay
>>710291251
Well dude, your bruised ego will recover. And now you know that speed does not generate power.
What do you think generated that speed to begin with? You need power to accomplish speed to begin with.
>>710291606
you address the wrong person
>>710281229
Neither, people who actually get laid win lmao
So to sum up: everybody who read the manga think guts would win. You cant compare the anime guts with the manga guts, its just the of bis story
>>710291938
Guts's party is a whole harem that follows him around, so there's that.
Without berserk armor? Geralt
With berserk armor? Guts
He literally doesn't even feel pain and the armor pseudo fixes injuries as he fights. Remember that the previous user of the armor kept fighting until he had lost literally all of his blood.
>>710281229
Obviously Guts
>>710292111
Only a single arc, and even then there are bits and pieces missing.
>>710291938
>life is actually worth something after i put benis into bagina xdddd
Fucking imbecile
>>710284444
>Quads being this wasted
>>710291285
It's a mind control spell. More suggestion than control. But, given Gutz is brute strength it's safe to assume he wouldn't have much defense against such a spell. Sure, pure will power will break him out of it, but that half a second that Yrden tells him to "take it easy for a few seconds, holding that big ass sword must be tiring huh? Go on, lower it for a minute or two, let your arm rest" and he does, just for a second, that's when Geralt will open his neck ear to ear. Nothing fancy. No cutting into dramatic chunks, no cleaving him in half. Just opening his neck, nice and wide.
In theory.
But Gutz is animu + main chara ability x manga-level luck. He would never lose, even when he loses.
https://discord.gg/d8XFBbH
come into our voice chat channel
we will discuss it all here
>>710291938
well guts wins then since he even literally fucked a monster
>>710292807
first page, baby
none of two has reasons to fight , butt only hypothetically scenario.
I think gutts a full capacity has no way to loose by strikes or just sword fight he is unstopable,
but Geralt its a Hunter a real and baddass hunter, like Batman, the preparation scenario of oils, bombs, potions, signs (like Yrden, or Axia) can make a serious advantage with one strike.
Depends of the first strike in my opinion, but i vote for geralt.
>>710292706
Guts is impervious to mind effects while in his skull suit. Also, he has Schierke with him for magical psychological support.
>>710292807
I miss when Berserk was actually raw, gritty and dark like this.
Now it feels like some PG-13 shit.
I mean, they just spent the last 5 years on a boat.
Looking for the Fairy King.
On the way to befriend a mermaid.
Now they have found the Fairy fucking King. Yes, a king. Of Fairies.
Is this some Disney shit or what?
>Look at that image, now look at this one.
Makes me wanna fucking cry. Especially because there's like 1 chapter every 4-6 months, then after every 3 chapters he takes a year off.
Why are we even discussing this?
Of course Geralt would lose. But that's only because of animes and their fucking infinite power levels.
>>710292807
Geralt too though
>>710284711
>gameplay is fine
I didn't know having all enemies stun locked with 3 hits then dodging their attack once they become temporarily immune to stunning was good game play.
>>710281229
The one with the hottest girl.
i love them both, but Guts the Cuck would win
Berserkers armor is much more powerful then any Geralts potion and signs
>>710293449
Exactly what I'm saying.
Manga Logic.
>I r instopable. Oh, u hab plan? I counter u with _____
>>710283116
Everyone i know has seen berserk, it is like saying watching pokemon when you were younger makes you a weeb
>>710292807
wait, he fuckin her? at that angle? how big his dick meant to be??
>>710293610
same anon.
it's because miura has been playing idolm@ster too fucking much kek.
joke aside, i think it's for pandering normies to read it. Grimdark fantasy like berserk would be too much for them.
>>710293610
If it was nothing but grit, then the impact would be less.
>>710293780
but it literally kills him
>>710293860
Well, yeah, man, that's how it is. I can't help it that gestalts not an unstoppable manga character. Guts can't even think while in his skull suit, it's just so much power.
Geralt has fucking magic, fuck you retards.
>>710293860
As opposed to potion chugging?
>>710293969
>how big his dick meant to be?
you'd be surprised
>>710294049
only if he takes to much damage and he would kill Geralt fast
>>710293610
kek, now that you've mentioned it, I can see it turning gradually into one piece.
>>710293969
he actually fucked a nice lady, but unfortunately she turned into her original form when he was about to cum, so he killed her afterward
>>710283829
idk I'd say he's this strong in the manga right now.
>>710284365
holy fuck that eastern design sounds like what they used for Illidan
>>710284666
fuck off Mr.Clean
>>710294738
super donkey punched her
>>710294029
Have you read it though?
It was perfect. Grit, grime, decay, disease, distress, destruction, madness, mayhem, blood, guts, Gutz, gore, friendship, companionship, love, lust, betrayal, all majestically thrown on an A5 canvas of creative gold.
Then he dun fucked up and turned the series into a fucking magic-based "revenge" drama where all he's actually done for the last 100 chapters is ride on a boat and make friends with and underage b& witch and a mermaid, looking for a "flowerstorm king" to heal the "love of his life" who acts like a fucking 5 year old. As a result of some really, really dark and twisted, fucked up shit that happened to her back when this shit was actually good!
>>710293610
he had to change it a bit
Guts alone is not going to get far, he only knows how to kill
he needs someone with brain
but its true it is turning in to shit at rapid rate
>>710281229
guts
>>710295052
I read berserk to see brutal action grit, grime and madness in the rawest form, now it is turning into fucking one piece.
>>710295052
I did, just, kinda in denial if you can say that.
>>710295849
>nakama
checked
>boat adventure
checked
>goofy designs
checked
>>710296058
Literally fucking sailing around on a boat with a cute little witch girl making fucking friends to find a fairy king, a fucking fairy king to heal his gf. What the fuck.
>>710286182
lmao this fucking edgelord weeb fuck
>>710296226
i have a hope this is just a calm period before it gets dark again to tease us
>>710296454
the problem is that the tease has lasted longer than the average manga artist career, and that man is going to die someday
>>710281229
geralt, cuz magic
>>710282846
if we rrunning weaboo physics, geralt gets even stronger.
If we r running real physics, guts cant lift that slab
>>710281229
GUTS
>>710296887
video game physics is real physics
>>710297061
physics is real. Its that magic influences it.
Even if thats your counterargument, we can run weaboo physics, or computer game physics. Geralt wins
Also geralt is from books, not games, so your argument is invalid.
>>710297363
well, guts is also from a book where the physics are real, but that wasn't my argument. My argument is that you're pushing a double standard or are just too stupid to realise that video games are also fiction and not real.
>>710297833
no1 in witcher universe of human posture can swing giant slabs of steel.
In berserk its normal.
Clearly there r discrepancies. Theres no double-standard. 1 stays as true to regular world, while other romaticizes it for coolness.
As i stated, u dense motherfucker - if we assume swinging dragonslayers is this easy, geralt still wins, cuz he can do it better
>>710298196
except he's the only one that can swing that sword.
but again you are not reading before responding.
Videogames are not real life, books are not real life. Fiction is not non fiction
Gattsu is king
>>710298574
uve got more wisdom like that? Like which letter in the alphabet is "A"?
Guts is not able to use dragonslayer. If he swings it, he will fly with it.
>>710299150
so video game physics is not real life physics?
>>710299326
so if guts can swing dragonslayer, whats stopping geralt from swinging equally stupid sword better?
>>710281229
Geralt.
Guts is a very fast and strong fighter. I'd consider him to be an inferior witcher though. He has the speed and power of a witcher for sure and his ability to sense attacks is great. However, he lacks the magic uses from the fight scenes I saw (fight a guy who can influence your mind and that's already an issue), he lacks the mutations to do nonhuman things like seeing in the dark or healing or any extra traits.
Due to traits I'd be inclined to say Geralt would win. Physically I'd consider them fairly equal despite Guts massive stature at 6'8" and Geralt at around 6' even. Maybe Guts being a bit stronger but that would be outmatched through abilities, potions and other witcher specific tools.
>>710299728
20 years of swinging a sword that was too big for him. But you're still pretending that everything in the witcher could work in the real world which makes me think you haven't read the books or played the games, and yet I'm certain you have.
Again the original point still stands, you are presenting a fallacy by claiming the witcher and the witcher alone is realistic in how its universe works.
>>710283829
>Guts was never this strong in the manga
>kills 30+ Makara within minutes
>Makara are literally blue whales mutated into sea monsters via magic
>Guts killed 30+ 100ft long sea monsters within minutes
>was never this strong
>>710300231
underlying physics is as we know them.
>20 years of waving a 2-hander prepared me to break angular momentum
original point doesnt stand. If guts can swing too big swords, so can geralt and better
So mad. Stay wrong.
>>710301381
the thing about the Dragonslayer has already been stated in this thread, it's essentially Mjolnir but slightly less magic. Guts is quite literally the only person alive that can use it, especially after it got steeped in astral energy. The Berserk universe does abide by it's own rules, and has real rules of physics for everyone, it's just that Guts is A. a raw battery of astral power due to surviving multiple Lovecraftian events and B. Dragonslayer is essentially magic.
FUCK ME, I Would Say Both Would End Up Killin Each Other Geralt Usin All His Potions And Guts Usin The Black Armor To His Death #EachMetTheirMatch
>>710281229
Whoever has seen bare boobies first
>>710301381
he doesn't swing two big swords. someone is taking this a little to personally for it to be healthy.
and if you had read the manga it shows how he gets around the weight, a lot of thought went into it.
and you can't read can you, geralt could use the dragonslayer if he grew up like guts. aka 20 years of swinging a sword that was too big for him.
>>710301996
its mjolnir but less magic? Like mjolnirr is normal hammer, but only thor can use it, while some prophecy says guts can use dragonslayer - the abnormal, giant, too heavy sword?
Geralt would be professionally slaying lovecraftian thigs too ang geralthas magic on top of being extra fast
>>710302340
>he doesnt swing 2 big swords
try reading, before accusing some1 of not being able to read.
20 years of killing monstrs and casting magic. u lose
>>710302891
awe you got me, still not as bad as not knowing what i had posted before and fucking up the conversation because of that. and its not like the phrase "too big swords" doesn't imply more than one sword with that s at the end of sword meaning plural.
Griffith pwnd guts because he was a better swordsman. Only when he was all butt hurt did he lose.
Geralt is a better swordsman. He has a hundred years of experience. Not to mention he could just torch guts, or freeze him, or blast him onto his ass before the first blow.
Berserker armor can't heal decapitation.
The only advantage is the cannon arm, but he can't use that in berserker armor.
