>>682853016 Incorrect. If founded with good timing (referring to the state of the country) and the right amount of resources, communism would succeed. My apologies for not going into detail, I am trying to answer all responses.
>>682853017 My definition of communism is a stateless brotherhood where man helps his fellow man. Obviously there is more, but this is a very simplified version.
>>682853212 Because I believe that government should control more things than just the police, the courts and the jails.
>>682853411 I don't understand what you're implying. My apologies.
>>682853475 The famines have been because of lack of resources and corruption, not communism itself.
>>682850701 Donald Trump, you are a gangster and which supports your chair, smell like sulfur I vote for those that never chose the easy path of history, i vote for Martin Luther King, i vote for David Dellinger, i vote for Sean Eldridge, i vote for Rosa Parks and for Eleanor Smeal, i vote for Nelson Mandela, I VOTE HILLARY.
>Be me >Ukrainian peasant under the Russian Empire >FML.png >A few cool dudes come to my eyes >They promote the idea of communism >Perhaps now, us Ukrainians will be treated as equals! >Fast forward a few years >Bolshevik victory >Cool beans >Wait, Stalin is now in charge >Still okay with this >More years later >Starving as fuck >DamnItStalin.gif >Have to eat literal shit while Russians are having a good giggle and stuffing their faces >Communism >Equality >10/10 Treatment
>>682854113 I feel very offended and angry. I myself study and practice Communism. However, I think we need a bit of a government. Not to control us, but rather to protect us all. Or do you ask for murder in the streets and chaos to take the lands?
>>682854819 The government would control basic things such as the courts, education, military, etc. Basic stuff. Religion would NOT be banned, but rather there would be a COMPLETE separation of religion and state. The fellow proletariat would be happy and work as hard as he could to support his community, while be taxed for his work, and he would be able to live freely with his fellow man in prosperity with a good amount of resources.
>>682856055 OP is kind've a moron, different commie here. There are no other counties in a communist society. Before world revolution there will be a socialist state, but this is not ideal and not the end goal for a communist. The USSR was a shitty socialist state because they didn't experience capitalism before their revolution.
>>682856055 Indeed, but with a lot more liberty than you think. In the past corruption and mismanagement have ruined the utopian communist economy but an actual communist economy would just regulate certain things agreed upon by the community. One aspect of communism that I would change, though, is that international trade be encouraged. It is better to globally trade. I could go into trade among the country if you wish.
>>682856576 I was going to go into that. Then again, you are most likely more knowledgeable about this than me. My apologies.
Sorry for being slow guys. I've been kind of busy.
>>682855818 Here are my ideas of how the perfect government would be.
Vote upon everything instead of letting others decide for us. Make every person economically and socially the same. Make education free and required for all. Have our careers and education decided for us so that the money isn't a wasted kindness. Publicly flog and execute any trouble maker. Have the media tell only the truth. No more lies to corrupt the common man. Give everybody the same house, clothing, and all that would make anybody different.
These are my views. Take them as wisdom or simply as a sight into my mind. I care not which you do.
>>682857056 Nah, I need to go eat dinner but thanks, it's been interesting. You haven't changed my opinion at all but you've given me some good insight which I appreciate. Also, you might find this cool. I have a communist era rifle under my bed (SKS). It has a commie star stamped on the receiver.
>>682857257 I agree except with the sameness. Communism supports equality, not sameness. Everyone should be able to receive what they'd like, act how they'd like, and absolutely NO flogging. Government should not harm its people. That is not communism. All of your other ideas I agree with, though.
>>682854113 How do you feel knowing that the main reason that communism and anarchism is flawed is due to the human nature of betrayal and overpowerment? Take stalin/lenin's relationship per example, with the sudden takeover of the politburo and betrayal by stalin and its "brothers"
>>682857634 But by showing what happens to those that step out of line, the common man is not tempted to commit such acts. And individuality breeds hatred for others. Racism, sexism, and many other forms of discrimination are a result of not being like the common man. Similarities do a fine job at killing of at least a bit of hatred.
Communism is gaining utopia through violent means, and ruling totalitarian till it is established there is no need for government. It always fails because the totalitarian ruler usually has no intentions of reaching absolute utopia. You sound like the people Marx distastes.
>>682858873 How is it irrelevant? Its the ground of what communism means. While it works in theory, communism will never work pratically, and the proofs are all in front of you. Name a single free communist dominant country where there is a stable and fair relationship between government and society.
Neither did Marx. And I doubt you would know how to properly run a country either. Communism can't exist properly and will never reach the final stages unless it relies on other forms of government and ideologies.
>>682859189 My friend, bless your soul. For your mind is fragile to this world. Violence is sometimes needed to end more violence. Or do you rather call for a police force simply asking murderers not to kill? Or are you asking for crime to be legal, no matter what it is? A man left to do his own devices will likely do horrible things, so he must be held back in the name of humanity. No matter the cost. We as a species must reach total unity or face more wars and the human race destroying itself. I pray that I may one day give some of my freedoms up in the name of humanity.
>>682860364 I know, don't worry my friend. Utopian non-violence will be almost impossible to reach. Which is why I, as a communist, do as much as I can to help the cause, to help us become a more communist utopian society, year by year.
It's not "Stalinism" you stupid, ignorant teenage edgelord cunt. There's no such thing as "Stalinism".
IT'S COMMUNISM UNDER STALIN
German National Socialism isn't "Hitlerism"
American Democracy isn't George W Bushism
The Westminster Parliament isn't Henry the VIIIism
The ideology of Communism fails because it reduces everyone to the lowest common denominator, everything is over-regulated to the extent that you have to pay for a license and seek government approval to do anything. To get a job, to travel, to write a book, to wipe your arse. Communism doesn't allow anyone to reform it with any ease because of its' ridiculously primitive administrative structure .
The only instance of it ever working is in China and it is only "works" because Communism is marginally less fucked up than having a dozen or so feudal warlords constantly fighting against each other.
If you're a think you're actually a communist and that this is a good thing then you lack life experience.
"First of all there is such a thing as Stalinism. Go look it up if you wish, Stalin changed a bunch of things for the worse." He sure did. My MiL was born in the gulag. Her mother lost her husband and 4 children.
>>682861944 ok, you seem like a nice gent, so I'm gonna be real with you. I don't have a goddamn lick of a clue what fuckin Night Feedings are. My friend told me to say that; However, I can inform you about Ear Squirts if you wish.
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.